We Bought Every Instant Coffee at Walmart and Ranked Them All

Instant coffee has a well-earned reputation for being terrible. But is there a drinkable option on the supermarket shelf? We bought every instant coffee at Walmart, brewed them all black following package instructions, and ranked them on a 10-point scale.

The results destroyed our expectations.

How Instant Coffee Is Made

Two methods, and the difference matters:

Spray-dried: Concentrated brewed coffee is sprayed into a chamber with hot air that flash-evaporates the liquid. Fast and cheap, but the heat damages aromatic oils and flavor compounds. Produces fine powder. Most budget instant coffee uses this method.

Freeze-dried: Coffee is brewed, frozen into slabs, then placed in a vacuum where ice sublimates directly to vapor at low temperatures. Because no heat is involved, more flavor compounds survive. Produces chunky granules. Costs more to manufacture.

The processing method matters more than the brand name — a well-made spray-dried coffee can beat a poorly made freeze-dried one, but in general, freeze-dried produces a cleaner, more flavorful cup.

The Rankings

All tasted black, filtered water at 195-205°F (not boiling — boiling water makes instant coffee taste burnt), one teaspoon per 6-8 oz cup.

Tier 1: Actually Good

Folgers Classic Roast (Medium) — 7/10

The biggest surprise. We expected thin and burnt. We got smooth, rich, zero bitter aftertaste. It tasted genuinely like a proper medium roast — something you’d choose to drink, not settle for. At under $5 per jar (dozens of cups), it’s pennies per serving. The best value in the entire test by a wide margin.

Tier 2: Solid Options

Juan Valdez Medium Roast — 6/10 Good flavor, pleasant aroma, no bitterness. A solid cup. But not significantly better than Folgers at double the price. The Colombian single-origin positioning loses distinctiveness in the spray-drying process.

Great Value Fresh and Smooth (Medium) — 6/10 The plot twist: Walmart’s store brand was one of the best. Smooth, not watery, good flavor. Slightly lighter than advertised but in a pleasant way. At less than 5 cents per cup, the value is extraordinary.

Maxwell House (Light with Cream and Sugar) — 6/10 A pre-mixed option, so not a direct comparison. Good flavor, not too sweet, pleasant. Slightly watery. Works for people who want grab-and-go convenience.

Tier 3: Mediocre

Taster’s Choice House Blend — 5/10 Heavier than expected for a “light medium.” Slight bitter aftertaste. Drinkable but forgettable.

Taster’s Choice Colombian — 4/10 Nice aroma but darker than labeled with lingering bitterness. You’d finish the cup but wouldn’t be excited about it.

Tier 4: Skip These

Starbucks Colombian Medium Roast — 3/10 Premium price, disappointing cup. Bold, bitter, artificial aftertaste. Starbucks’ strength is fresh-brewed coffee — their instant line feels like an afterthought. (For comparison, their packaged whole beans are much better — see our Peet’s vs Starbucks comparison for how they stack up.)

Starbucks French Roast (Dark) — 2/10 Smoother than their Colombian but ruined by a lingering acidic aftertaste. Did not finish the cup.

Nescafe Clasico (Dark) — 2/10 Strong, acidic, unpleasant aftertaste. The kind of instant coffee that gives instant coffee its bad reputation. Did not finish.

The Lesson: Price Doesn’t Predict Quality

The two most expensive options (both Starbucks) finished dead last. The two best were Folgers and Walmart’s house brand. You literally cannot judge instant coffee by its label or price tag.

Tips for Better Instant Coffee

Don’t use boiling water. Let it cool 30 seconds after boiling, or target 195-205°F. Boiling water extracts harsh, burnt flavors from instant coffee. This matters for regular brewing too — our ideal coffee brewing temperature guide explains the science.

Stir for 20-30 seconds. Instant coffee doesn’t always dissolve fully. Thorough stirring makes a noticeable difference.

Use filtered water. Chlorine and minerals in tap water mask coffee flavor.

Use it within 2-3 months of opening. Instant coffee degrades once the jar is opened, especially if moisture gets in.

When Instant Coffee Makes Sense

Instant coffee isn’t trying to replace fresh-brewed — it serves a different purpose:

• Travel and camping — no equipment needed
• Office backup — when the good coffee runs out
• Speed — 5 seconds beats 5 minutes some mornings
• Baking — instant coffee dissolves better than brewed for recipes

For daily drinking at home, a $15 French press and decent whole beans will always produce a better cup. Or try the AeroPress for a portable but still excellent brew. But when you need instant, Folgers Classic Roast or Great Value Fresh and Smooth are genuinely drinkable — and cost less than the “premium” options that taste worse.

Some links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.